Contractor vs. Employee in 2025

How the U.S. Department of Labor’s New Rule Redraws the Line—and What It Means for Your Workforce

1. Background: Why worker status keeps shifting

The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) guarantees minimum wage and overtime only to employees. Independent contractors generally receive none of those protections, which means classification errors expose companies to back wages, tax penalties, and class-action litigation.

In January 2024, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) published a final rule that replaced the 2021 “core-factor” test with a more expansive six-factor economic-reality analysis. The rule became effective March 11 2024 and remains in force after a series of court challenges were rejected in early 2025. Federal RegisterReuters

---

2. The six economic-reality factors—explained in plain language

Factor	Practical questions DOL (and courts) will ask	Illustrative signs of employee status	Illustrative signs of independent contractor status
1. Opportunity for profit or loss depending on managerial skill	Can the worker raise income through marketing, hiring helpers, or investing in better tools?	Paid flat hourly rate; no say in pricing; no marketing spend	Sets own rates; advertises services; decides which jobs to accept
2. Investments by worker and employer	Whose capital is at risk?	Uses company computer, software, workspace	Buys own equipment; carries business insurance
3. Degree of permanence of the relationship	Is the engagement open-ended or tied to a project?	Indefinite term; auto-renewing SOWs	One-off project; renewable only by new proposal
4. Nature and degree of control	Who sets schedule, location, and work processes?	Mandatory 9-to-5, on-site supervision, detailed SOPs	Chooses hours, sequence, and tools; minimal check-ins
5. Integral part of the employer’s business	Is the work central to the company’s core offering?	Primary product development for a software firm	Provides specialized, non-core service (e.g., brand photography)
6. Skill and initiative	Does the worker deploy specialized skill in a market?	Entry-level tasks trained in-house	Distinct expertise marketed to multiple clients

No single element is decisive; the DOL instructs investigators to weigh the totality of circumstances. DOL

---

3. How the 2024 rule differs from the 2021 standard

2021 “core-factor” rule (rescinded)	2024 rule now in effect
Two “core” factors (control; profit/loss opportunity) dominated analysis; other factors rarely tipped the outcome.	All six factors carry equal weight; additional facts may be considered if relevant.
Example favored gig-economy platforms; control delivered through apps was often labeled “business model” rather than supervision.	Control exercised through algorithms, ratings, or mandatory acceptance windows now counts toward employee status.
Adopted late in the previous administration; never fully implemented after litigation.	Finalized after notice-and-comment; upheld by federal court (Jan 2025). Reuters

---

4. Interaction with other tests (IRS and states)

• IRS 20-factor common-law test. Federal tax authorities still rely on right-to-control principles. The new DOL rule overlaps but is not identical, so a worker could be an employee for payroll tax purposes even if classified as a contractor under another federal scheme. IRS
  
• State “ABC” statutes. California, Massachusetts, New Jersey, and others presume employee status unless the hiring entity proves A) autonomy, B) work performed outside usual business, C) independent trade. The federal rule does not pre-empt stricter state laws.
  
• Agency-specific rules. The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) and Department of the Treasury apply their own multi-factor tests. Companies must satisfy all relevant bodies.
  
  

---

5. Enforcement posture in 2025

The Wage and Hour Division issued Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-1 confirming that, while litigation continues, the agency is enforcing the six-factor standard in investigations and will “prioritize industries with high misclassification risk, including logistics, home care, and app-based delivery.” DOL

Civil monetary penalties for repeat or willful violations can exceed $2,500 per worker, exclusive of back wages and liquidated damages. Private class actions frequently settle in the seven-figure range once overtime and benefit claims are tallied.

---

6. Practical steps for employers

1. Conduct a workforce audit.
   
   • List every 1099 engagement; map duties against the six factors.
     
   • Flag roles with fixed schedules, ongoing tasks, and company-issued equipment.
     
2. Update contracts to reflect reality.
   
   • Avoid “right-to-control” provisions unless truly necessary (e.g., safety standards).
     
   • Include clear project scope, deliverables, and the contractor’s right to subcontract or advertise.
     
3. Align pay practices.
   
   • Eliminate time-tracking apps that measure start/stop times for contractors—use milestone payments instead.
     
   • Require invoices with itemized services and federal EINs.
     
4. Document entrepreneurial indicators.
   
   • Retain evidence of contractor marketing (website, LinkedIn page) and investments (equipment receipts).
     
5. Monitor state developments.
   
   • If operating in ABC states, verify that contracted services are “outside the usual course of business.”
     
6. Budget for reclassification.
   
   • Factor in payroll taxes (≈ 7.65 %), overtime exposure, benefit eligibility, and potential retroactive penalties.
     
     

---

7. Guidance for workers and freelancers

• Clarify ownership of tools and IP. Maintain your own software licenses, laptops, and insurance when feasible.
  
• Issue formal invoices and set rates independently to strengthen entrepreneurial profile.
  
• Balance client portfolio. Over-reliance on one customer weakens contractor status.
  
• Sign robust independent-contractor agreements that describe limited control and project-based work—but remember: documents help only if day-to-day reality matches.
  
  

---

8. Frequently asked questions

Q. Does paying a flat project fee instead of hourly wages ensure contractor status?
A. Not by itself. Payment structure is only one data point within Factor 1. Courts still examine control, permanence, and integration.

Q. We use a gig-platform to onboard freelancers—does the platform shield us?
A. No. If your company directs the work or reaps its benefits, you may still be the “joint employer” under the FLSA.

Q. Can we offer training to contractors?
A. Minimal orientation is permissible, but mandatory in-depth training that dictates methods can signal employee control.

---

9. Timeline for compliance

Month	Milestone
May 2025	Launch internal audit; identify high-risk roles.
June 2025	Amend or replace independent-contractor agreements; adjust payment systems.
July 2025	Provide compliance training for hiring managers and project leads.
Q4 2025	Re-audit and document ongoing contractor independence (e.g., diversified client base).

---

10. Key takeaways

1. Six factors, equal weight. The DOL now emphasizes a holistic view of economic dependence.
   
2. Documentation counts, but conduct rules. Written contracts that conflict with day-to-day reality will be disregarded.
   
3. State and federal tests stack. Meeting the DOL rule does not guarantee compliance with IRS, NLRB, or state ABC standards.
   
4. Early audits beat late litigation. Proactive classification reviews cost a fraction of FLSA class-action settlements.
   
   

---

Need an independent-contractor audit or agreement refresh?

Colella Legal Studio advises businesses nationwide on worker-classification strategies, contract drafting, and state-specific compliance. Schedule a 30-minute consultation to mitigate misclassification risk before the next DOL inquiry lands on your desk.